01 · The genie is out of the bottle
AI is not going away.
Whether I like it or not, AI is here to stay. Putting my head in the sand does not make it disappear. It only means I miss the chance to point it at something worth doing.
I would rather use the technology to preserve the demoscene, and where possible to improve how it is remembered and explained, than watch forty years of tricks slowly vanish into dead links and unreadable source.
02 · Not everyone is a day-one assembler coder
Enthusiasm is not a crime.
Demo crews were always more than coders. There were musicians, graphicians, swappers and organisers. I was a musician in Trepaan and MAJESTiC. I lived the scene and marvelled at the effects, but I was never the low-level assembler coder from the very first hour with a natural gift for maths.
In the new rendition of MAJESTiC I code. Actually, I do everything. And I largely have AI to thank for that. I wanted to know how those effects worked and to be able to make them myself. AI helped me understand them, and because of that I was able to build my own software-rendering engine in .NET. Had I let AI do the programming, I would have ended up choosing sleek GPU shader stuff instead.
That does not make the enthusiasm wrong, or the intention false. Wanting to understand and preserve the magic is exactly what the scene was always about.
03 · Precision, as far as I am able
I use AI to make what I want.
AI is the tool, not the author of the intent. I decide what gets built and I do it as precisely as I can, within the limits of my own ability: every version renders live, retro versions are pinned to the resolution and palette of their platform, and every timeline milestone links back to the demo on Pouët or Demozoo.
Where I am not sure, I say so. Where I get it wrong, I want to know.
04 · About the 'AI slop' threads
That label kicks well-meaning sceners in the gut.
I take real offence at the current threads on Pouët that dismiss anything touched by AI as slop. Slop is low-effort volume made for clicks. Throwing honest, careful work onto the same pile hits people who are trying to give something back to the scene they love.
Criticise the work, please. Point at the wrong palette, the broken timing, the missing prod. That makes this better. A blanket label does not.